CellarTracker is brilliant at what it does — community reviews, 20 years of data, a database of millions of wines. But it was built in 2003 to answer one question: what bottles do I own? Serious collectors in 2026 are asking something different. What is my collection worth today? What should I sell? What's at peak and about to decline? CellarTracker can't answer those questions. Cellar IQ was built to. (For the full side-by-side, see our Cellar IQ vs CellarTracker comparison →)
Already have access? Sign in →
| Feature | CellarTracker | Cellar IQ |
|---|---|---|
| Bottle inventory tracking | ✓ | ✓ |
| Community tasting notes | ✓ 10M+ tasting notes | — |
| Market price data | ✓ Subscriber-only | ✓ Live |
| Gain / loss vs cost basis | ✗ | ✓ |
| Portfolio value over time | ✗ | ✓ |
| Drinking window alerts | ✓ | ✓ |
| AI sommelier | — Recommendations only | ✓ Full collection context |
| Whisky & spirits valuation | ✓ Wine-focused | ✓ Wine + whisky |
| Weekly agentic scan | ✗ | ✓ |
| Mobile experience | ✓ | ✓ |
| CellarTracker import | — | ✓ One click |
| Price | Free / $40–500/yr by cellar size | Free during early access |
We have enormous respect for CellarTracker. Its community data is unmatched, and millions of collectors rely on it. But there are questions it was never designed to answer — and for serious collectors, those are exactly the questions that matter most.
CellarTracker shows what you paid and what the market says it's worth. But it never tells you your actual gain or loss — the delta between cost basis and current value across your whole collection.
CellarTracker doesn't fire alerts when auction prices spike, when a vintage approaches its window ceiling, or when a bottle hits peak. You find out by accident, or not at all.
CellarTracker shows what your cellar is worth in aggregate, but no per-producer or per-vintage performance, no return analytics tied to time held, no view of which positions are appreciating or declining over time. Your cellar is treated as a list of bottles, not a financial asset.
If your cellar is reds and whisky — most serious cellars are — the whisky side carries real value. Cellar IQ prices it alongside the wine. CellarTracker can log spirits, but its published valuation methodology is wine-focused, and many spirit entries may not have automatic valuation data available.
Your CellarTracker data doesn't have to stay in CellarTracker. Cellar IQ imports your full collection from a single CSV — producer, wine, vintage, quantity, size, drinking windows, your private notes, and your personal scores. (Want to know exactly what comes down with the CSV — and what doesn't? Read our CellarTracker export guide →) Export your CellarTracker CSV, upload it, and your cellar is live. No manual re-entry. No starting over.
In CellarTracker, go to Reports → Export → Download your full cellar as a CSV file.
Sign up free, go to Import, and upload your CSV. We handle the column mapping automatically.
Your full collection is live — valued, with gain/loss analytics and your AI sommelier ready to go.
I used CellarTracker for over a decade and loved it. It tracks what's in my cellar with a depth and a community no one else has matched.
But somewhere along the way, my collection stopped being a hobby and started being a portfolio. I had bottles I'd held for fifteen years and didn't know what they were worth. I had wines crossing into peak I'd forgotten about. I had whisky CellarTracker was never built to track.
I built Cellar IQ to answer the questions CellarTracker wasn't designed for: what is my collection worth today, what should I sell, what should I drink, what should I do next?
— Arif Razvi, Founder
No. Importing into Cellar IQ doesn't change anything in CellarTracker. Your CellarTracker account, your data, and your community notes stay exactly where they are. Use both for as long as you want.
Your core data imports cleanly: producer, wine, vintage, quantity, size, country, appellation, varietal, drinking windows, your private notes, and your personal scores. CellarTracker's community tasting notes and per-vintage critic scores stay in CellarTracker — they're not ours to import. If you want to keep referencing those, keep your CellarTracker account active alongside Cellar IQ.
No. CellarTracker and Cellar IQ do different jobs. CellarTracker is a catalog tool with community tasting notes. Cellar IQ is a portfolio tool with live valuations and AI intelligence. Use both, use one, or switch back. Your call.
We've tested imports without timeout on cellars up to 5,000 bottles. The CellarTracker export is a single CSV — upload it and our AI handles column mapping automatically.
Our reference database covers 200,000+ wines and whiskies — most major producers, vintages, and labels. For bottles outside the database, you can add them manually with autocomplete to speed it up. For bottles without secondary-market data, you can enter the value yourself.
Yes. You own your data. Export your full cellar as CSV any time from Settings → Your Data — no questions asked.
Your collection reveals where valuable assets are stored — we treat the data accordingly. Encrypted connections in transit, hashed passwords, and row-level access controls so only you can see your cellar. We never sell or share your data, and you can export or delete it any time.
Nothing during early access. No credit card, no trial clock.
Bring your full CellarTracker collection in one CSV upload. Free during early access.
Already have access? Sign in →