Cellar IQ is an AI-powered portfolio tracker for wine and whisky collectors that adds valuation analytics and a weekly Brief on top of the cellar records you already keep — including in CellarTracker. CellarTracker is the benchmark for cellar record-keeping and community tasting notes, and nothing here argues otherwise. This is not a switch decision. It's a stack decision.
The short version: CellarTracker is where your cellar's story lives — what you own, what you and millions of tasting notes think of it. Cellar IQ is where your cellar's value lives — what it's worth this week, what's moving, and which bottles are asking for a decision. We designed Cellar IQ to run alongside CellarTracker, not replace it. Most collections import in minutes.
CellarTracker excels at recording wine history — purchases, locations, consumption, tasting notes. Cellar IQ focuses on valuation, portfolio monitoring, and collection analytics. Because the two solve different problems, they complement each other rather than compete.
Informational only. Not investment advice.
The comparison
| Dimension | Cellar IQ | CellarTracker |
|---|---|---|
| Primary purpose | Portfolio valuation and monitoring | Cellar records and community tasting notes |
| Community tasting notes | — | More than ten million notes — among the largest wine review databases in the world |
| Valuation data | Weekly median of current retail offers (replacement value); on-demand refresh with full access; resale value from auction results in development | Auction averages (Wine Market Journal), updated quarterly; community averages; user-entered values |
| Valuation coverage transparency | Coverage shown per cellar (valued and unmatched bottles counted) | Cascading fallback (auction → community → purchase price); as published, the source tier isn't shown per bottle |
| Value history | Price history per wine, up to 90 days on each holding | Most recent quarter + up to 6 months of auction history; full history requires a separate Wine Market Journal subscription |
| Portfolio analytics | Gain/loss and return on cost basis, concentration, allocation, vintage × region performance, weekly movers | Collection charts (cellar size, drinking-window distribution, region/variety); value shown as totals |
| Whisky & spirits value | Valued alongside wine where market data exists | Spirits can be inventoried, though the published valuation methodology is wine-focused and many spirit entries may not have automatic valuation data |
| Drinking windows | Window status per bottle, with closing windows flagged in the weekly brief | Drinking windows with enhanced coverage (subscriber feature); drinkability reports |
| Price | Free plan available now; full access free through at least March 31, 2027. There will always be a free plan. | Free for inventory + community notes; valuation and most features require a subscription: $40–$500/yr by cellar size |
Where CellarTracker is the right answer
Twenty-plus years, hundreds of thousands of collectors, hundreds of millions of bottles tracked, and more than ten million community tasting notes — among the largest wine review databases in the world. If you want to know how the 2016 Brunello you're considering actually drinks tonight, CellarTracker is where that answer lives.
Its valuation feature is also genuinely credible. Subscribers get auction-market averages from the Wine Market Journal — real hammer prices from major auction houses, grossed up to replacement cost — alongside community-entered values for wines the auction market doesn't trade. For insurance purposes, which is how CellarTracker itself frames the feature, that's the right number built the right way.
Both numbers are replacement-style values. CellarTracker's is a quarterly auction average grossed up to replacement cost; ours is the weekly median of current retail offers. The difference is cadence, a dollar-axis analytics layer, and coverage shown for your cellar — with a resale value based on auction results in development.
And the record-keeping is the deepest in the category: per-purchase provenance, storage locations, consumption history, barcoding. As a system of record, it's indispensable. We tell people to keep it. We mean it.
Where Cellar IQ adds a portfolio layer
Cellar IQ starts where the system of record stops: treating the same bottles as a portfolio.
A weekly value instead of a quarterly average. Cellar IQ reprices your collection every week at the median of current retail offers — and on demand with full access. CellarTracker's auction valuations update quarterly. A bottle that moved 20% in three weeks shows up in your Monday scan, not next quarter's average.
Analytics with a dollar axis. Where your value is concentrated, which vintages and regions are doing the work, what's pulling the portfolio up and what's dragging it down, gain and loss against what you actually paid. CellarTracker's published chart set describes the collection — cellar size over time, drinking-window distribution, and breakdowns by variety, region, color, and vineyard. Cellar IQ's describe the value.
A weekly brief. Every Monday it flags bottles whose drinking window has closed or closes this year — with how many reviews support each window — and the week's biggest price moves. The signals come to you; the judgment calls stay yours.
Whisky counts. If your cellar is reds and whisky — most serious cellars are — the whisky side carries real value. Cellar IQ values whisky alongside wine where market data exists. CellarTracker can log spirits, but its published valuation methodology is wine-focused, and many spirit entries may not have automatic valuation data available.
Honesty about coverage. No pricing source covers everything. Cellar IQ shows you exactly which bottles it can price and which it can't, with a coverage figure on the analytics view — so you know what your number is made of. Valuations are the median of current retail offers (replacement value) and may differ from what a bottle would realize at sale.
Using both: the setup
- Export your cellar from CellarTracker: On CellarTracker’s desktop site, open My Cellar, click Export (top right), choose “Wines from all pages”, tick every column category, and choose CSV. Exports are free — no CellarTracker subscription needed. (Full walkthrough in our CellarTracker export guide.)
- Import into Cellar IQ. Purchase prices, quantities, and vintages come across; your CellarTracker records stay exactly where they are. Most collections import in minutes.
- Your first weekly brief arrives within the week, with values on the bottles the market data covers.
Keep logging purchases and tasting notes in CellarTracker if that's your habit. Cellar IQ doesn't replace the record — it reads the portfolio.
See what your cellar is worth
Sign up free. Import your CellarTracker collection in one CSV upload. First weekly scan within the week.
Import your CellarTracker cellar →Frequently asked questions
Informational only. Not investment advice. Valuations are the median of current retail offers (replacement value) and may differ from what a bottle would realize at sale.